//

Big Ten Bloggers Roundtable Week 3

Hosted by Lake the Posts

1)The national media is using the Big Ten Conference as a punching bag in 2008 ranking us somewhere between the Big East and the MAC. Based on Ohio State’s no-show, Purdue’s “APPLE!!!” and Michigan’s debacle, it is redemption week in Big Ten Country. However, several teams have very respectable, yet no-name teams (ie. Troy, Central Michigan, Ball State). Tell us how the Big Ten will respond this week in the final week before conference play.

Minnesota’s dream run of an undefeated season will probably come to an end, as they’re playing a pretty legit (though only 1-win thus far) Florida Atlantic squad. All the other Big Ten teams should win this week, however (and Minnesota might be able to continue surprising us). Ohio State will take down the Troy Trojans, against whom they’ll have a mascot-oriented grudge. Penn State should continue to climb up the charts with an impressive win over Temple. Northwestern and Indiana should take down MAC foes Ohio and Ball State, respectively, though both Mid-American teams are pretty good. Michigan State should avenge their Big Brother against Notre Dame. Purdue has a testy game against Central Michigan, and Iowa takes on a Pitt team that expected to be undefeated at this point, and has a bye week to prepare. Both Big Ten teams should struggle, but emerge victorious.

2)The conference standings look like someone took the 2007 results and flipped it upside down. Which of the undefeated teams are contenders and which are pretenders (another way of saying which teams have put lipstick on a pig)? Recalibrate your preseason rankings and tell us who the conference favorites are now.

The remaining undefeated teams are Indiana, Iowa, Minnesota, Northwestern, Penn State, and Wisconsin. Of those teams, Indiana, Iowa, Minnesota, and Northwestern are virtually untested. Indiana will challenge for a second-consecutive bowl, and Iowa and Northwestern will try to return to the postseason. Minnesota will struggle to get bowl-eligible once they start playing Actual Football Teams, and will probably fail to accomplish that. Penn State and Wisconsin are legit conference title contenders.

Among teams that have at least one loss, Ohio State will be a conference contender, and Michigan State and Illinois will probably sit around that second tier of the conference. I think Purdue is overrated, and will struggle for bowl eligibility, though they’ll probably scrape their way in. Michigan’s goal is to try to get into a bowl, and that’s as high as they’ll likely go.

3)Javon Ringer has emerged as the early season best-bet Heisman hopeful from the Big Ten. Real deal or non-conference smoke screen? Does anyone from the Big Ten have a prayer for the Heisman, or is it too late?

Javon Ringer might have a chance, but he’d have to put up those silly numbers against Actual Football Teams (he probably won’t: the Spartans aren’t that good), and the Spartans will have to challenge for the BCS (they probably won’t: the Spartans aren’t that good). The other preseason contenders in the conference were Curtis Painter, who won’t challenge for the Heisman because he never deserved to be in the conversation in the first place, and Beanie Wells, whose two games missed, including a pantsing of the Buckeyes by USC, will eliminate him from contention unless he goes for 200 yards and 2 touchdowns in nearly every game, while the Buckeyes make it back to the BCS (they probably will, or at least come close).

4)After three weeks it is time to give your team a new slogan. What is it and why is it what it is?

I’ll quote Rich Rodriguez on this one: “Michigan football will be back.” Sure, it sounds like a concession that this season is lost, and we’ll start focusing on the future. However, I don’t see it like that Michigan football will not wait until 2009 to return. on the contrary, the reemergence begins September 27th against the Badgers, and will continue through the following 8 games. Michigan football will be back this year, and that means at least a token run at the Big Ten Championship.

5)By now, you’ve likely adopted a favorite non Big Ten team to watch. Flex your football worldliness by convincing your fellow Big Ten kool-aid drinkers to watch your “other” team.

I have a very hierarchical method of determining who to cheer for, and it is to complicated to explain in depth in such a limited space. However, I generally cheer for the MAC (especially the state of Michigan teams or those that Michigan plays), because I think it is good for the Big Ten for Midwest football to be strong. I also cheer for the underdog most of the time, which may explain my recent adopting of Stanford. I also cheer against the SEC in non-conference games almost without exception (maybe if they played Notre Dame).

Posted under Analysis

Comments Off on Big Ten Bloggers Roundtable Week 3

Tags:

Blogpoll Final Ballot: Week 3

Rank Team Delta
1 Southern Cal
2 Oklahoma
3 Florida 1
4 Georgia 1
5 Texas 1
6 LSU 1
7 Penn State 1
8 Missouri 1
9 Wisconsin 1
10 Ohio State 5
11 East Carolina 5
12 Oklahoma State 2
13 South Florida 2
14 Brigham Young 12
15 Auburn 4
16 Utah 1
17 Texas Tech 1
18 Oregon 5
19 Kansas 1
20 Alabama 8
21 Wake Forest 3
22 West Virginia
23 Fresno State 3
24 Miami (Florida) 1
25 Illinois 2

Dropped Out: California (#19), Arizona State (#21).

Changes from Draft: Moved Oklahoma back ahead of Florida, and gave BYU a little bump to account for their shellacking of UCLA.

Posted under BlogPoll

Comments Off on Blogpoll Final Ballot: Week 3

Tags:

Notre Dame Game in Allusions

I’ve decided this will be a semi-regular feature. I really couldn’t think of anything for Miami but there’s plenty in this game.

The Weather is Straight out of The Odyssey. You know how Odysseus and a few of his men get stuck in Cyclops’s cave? They took some timber, sharpened an end and blinded Cyclops and then escaped by lashing themselves to the undersides of his sheep, so they slip out without being detected. Well, unfortunately for them Cyclops was Poseidon’s son, and Poseidon controls the weather on the ocean. Poseidon was angry that they did that to his son and whipped up a storm that sunk every boat save Odysseus’ and knocked his off into the edge of the world. I’m not sure what giant creature Rich Rodriguez blinded, but whichever deity controls the weather in South Bend sure as hell was pissed. The kicker is that this malevolent deity waited until its team was up by double digits before unleashing its wrath. Crafty…

Jimmy Clausen is Portia from The Merchant of Venice. Portia is definitely the hero of this play, and Jimmy Clausen was arguably the hero of the game on Saturday. I would personally say Michigan’s slippery hands were the hero, but if you want a person, Jimmy will do. The short version of this joke is that Portia is a women who dresses up as a man to save the day. I mean, have you seen Clausen’s hair? The longer story, is that she went to save Antonio who was in danger of losing a pound of flesh as he guaranteed his friend’s, Basonio, loan. Basonio is inept at his job, but still manages to land Portia, a wealthy heiress, by performing an arbitrary task. Weis, on the same token, is an inept coach who managed to land a very highly regarded (albeit feminine) recruit, most likely by consuming two whole turkeys. I’m not sure who Antonio would be. Maybe Jack Swarbick, Notre Dame’s Atheltic Director. The main components of Antonio are loyalty, a basic level of competancy and a strong hatred of jews, so maybe? I don’t judge.

Finally…

The Game in General
is The Jungle by Upton Sinclair. The main character, Jurgis Rudkus, is a Lithuanian immigrant fresh off the boat (well, that plus the trip to Chicago). He has an indomitable love for the American dream of pulling himself up by the bootstraps. Jurgis could be Michigan in general. Stepping bravely into new uncharted lands with a firm belief that, despite toil and tribulations, there is a higher goal that will inevitably be achieved. Early on in the novel, tragedy strikes quickly in the form of unscrupulous guests taking advantage of a wedding party and even taking what few donations were given leaving the family with nothing. Similarly, right out of the gate some players coughed up the ball and Michigan was left with a 21 point debt.

Although the main point of The Jungle may have been an evisceration of capitalism in favor of socialism (which some may agree with), the main thing I remember about the novel is a couple good things happening to Jurgis and then some massive tragedy coming out of left field. For example:

  1. Jurgis gets a job
  2. The women of the family were able to scrounge and make a nice meal
  3. Jurgis‘ son drowns in the mud while Jurgis is working.

In the game, most of what happened was good: McGuffie looked dominant, Threet looked acceptable++ and the receivers were making plays, but then there would be a hope killing turnover. Eventually it was too much for Jurgis (Rodriguez) to deal with and he just gave up (put in Sheridan*). The last hundred or so pages are basically socialist propaganda which, if you’ve been over to Wolverine Liberation Army since the game, you got as well. Sometimes these are just eerie…

*Reports are Threet came out with cramps, which seems like a logical answer.

Posted under Analysis

Comments Off on Notre Dame Game in Allusions

Tags: , , ,

Recruiting Update 9-16-08

As always, the board.

Moved to Committed:
NJ DE Anthony LaLota. Woo! A defensive end!

Added:
FL LB Mike Marry. Michigan shall make his next cut (info in header).

New Information:
OK RB David Oku. Never mind about deciding this week: he has delayed his announcement yet again.
FL QB Denard Robinson. Still feelin’ Michigan (info in header) despite the multiple QB commits.
SC OL Quinton Washington. Official visit for Wisconsin game, and Michigan looks surprisingly strong in his recruitiment (Sam Webb audio).
AZ DE Craig Roh. Sam Webb thinks he’ll end up at Michigan, unless Rick Neuheisel is particularly slimy (audio).
SC DE Sam Montgomery. Has decided which 5 schools to visit, including Michigan.
MI S Thomas Gordon. Announcing in a couple weeks, and MIchigan looks good (audio same as above).

Etc.:
2008 MI DE Nick Perry qualified on time, and is now at USC. It was thought that if he failed t qualify, Michigan might be back in the picture for him.
2008 NJ LB Marcus Witherspoon ended up at Rutgers, where he will be eligible to play this year.
FL DB Corey Addison. He is thinking about an official visit to Michigan. His commitment to SoCar will leave him off the board for now, but keep him in mind.

Analysis:
Michigan finally grabs a defensive end. If they can grab Craig Roh, a huge weakness will be accounted for at the position.

As of now, I expect to see Roh, Will Campbell, Thomas Gordon, and maybe another guy or two to finish out the class.

Posted under Recruiting

Blogpoll Preliminary Ballot: Week 3

Rank Team Delta
1 Southern Cal
2 Florida 2
3 Oklahoma 1
4 Georgia 1
5 Texas 1
6 LSU 1
7 Penn State 1
8 Missouri 1
9 Wisconsin 1
10 Ohio State 5
11 East Carolina 5
12 Oklahoma State 2
13 South Florida 2
14 Auburn 3
15 Utah 2
16 Texas Tech 2
17 Oregon 4
18 Brigham Young 8
19 Kansas 1
20 Alabama 8
21 Wake Forest 3
22 West Virginia
23 Fresno State 3
24 Miami (Florida) 1
25 Illinois 2

Dropped Out: California (#19), Arizona State (#21).

Games watched:
Most of UNC-Rutgers, Kansas-USF, Michigan State-FAU, Iowa-Iowa State, portions of Maryland-Cal, Northwestern-SIU, Michigan-Notre Dame, Most of PSU-Syracuse, portions of UGa-SoCar, Much of Auburn-Miss St, OSU-USC, Most of Oklahoma-Washington, Wisconsin-Fresno St.

I actually have a couple more games on DVR that I’ll watch before submitting my final ballot. I didn’t thoroughly look at last week’s final ballot when I put this together, so there might be a few inconsistencies I have to correct.

Posted under BlogPoll

Friday Night Lights 2009: September 14

CA QB Tate Forcier
Scripps Ranch had a bye week.

TX QB Shavodrick Beaver
Rider loses to Sulphur Springs (on ESPN2) 16-22.
Beaver’s stats: 21-33 (63.6%) for 249 yards (7.55 yds/att) and 2 TDs. 18 rushes, 84 yards (4.67 yds/att).
Video:

MI RB Teric Jones
Cass Tech beats Crockett 26-6.
Jones had over 200 yards, can’t find exactly how many.

OH RB Fitzgerald Toussaint
Liberty defeats Struthers 32-14.
Toussaint rushes 19 times for 258 yards (13.6 ypc) and 4 TDs, of 72, 57, 37, and 35 yards. Take out the TDs and he rushed 15 times for 57 yards (3.8 ypc).

FL RB Vincent Smith
Pahokee beats King’s Academy 40-7.
Smith had “over 100 yards” and a touchdown.

MN WR Bryce McNeal
Breck beats St. Bernard’s 35-33.
McNeal has an 85-yard kickoff return TD, igniting a big comeback.

FL Slot Jeremy Gallon
Apopka beats Freedom 57-21.

IL OL Michael Schofield
Sandburg beats Stagg 20-8.

LA DT DeQuinta Jones
Bastrop beats Dollarway 42-6.
No Jones mention.

NJ DE Anthony LaLota
Hun loses to Wyoming Seminary Prep 0-10.

FL LB Brandin Hawthorne
Pahokee beats King’s Academy 40-7.
No Hawthorne mention.

IN LB Jordan Barnes
Homestead beats Columbia City 28-9.

FL LB/S Mike Jones
Edgewater loses to Tallahassee Lincoln 14-30.

OH S Isaiah Bell
Liberty defeats Struthers 32-14.
No Bell mention in the article.

OH CB Justin Turner
Washington loses 13-23 to Youngstown Ursuline.
Turner had a 13-yard TD reception.

TX CB/WR DeWayne Peace
South Grand Prairie beats Summit 16-7.
Peace had an 85-yard TD reception, consisting of him catching a short pass over the middle shaking a couple defenders, and running a long way.

TX K Anthony Fera
Game canceled due to hurricane.

As always, if you have anything to share, let me know in the comments.

Posted under Recruiting

Slightly Less Immediate Reactions

The refs were truly brutal in this game. I certainly won’t blame them for the end result, but they definitely had a hand in getting the game there. Awful PI calls on Warren, a somewhat questionable one on Trent, and a catch by Mathews gave the Irish about a 15 point swing, and when playing from behind, players are more likely to take risks to make a big play. Also, the Grady fumble should have been called dead for forward progress. That was a hell of a missed call. Again, the players are ultimately responsible for the result, but this is a young team that didn’t really deserve the help in beating itself.

The defensive line was kinda crappy. Though they ultimately allowed ND to get only 3.3 yards for each carry, they gave up some critical yards in the third and fourth quarters. Still, when the defense only gives up 1 or 2 scoring drives (one ND TD “drive” started at the Michigan 11, one at the Michigan 14, two were composed almost entirely of a long pass to Golden Tate, and the final TD was scored on defense), it’s hard to find a ton of fault on that side of the ball.

Steven Threet, as predicted by many, has settled down the more game reps he has gotten. He finally calmed down enough to execute the throws that he was floating before. Then Sheridan came in a reminded Michigan fans why they should want Threet to succeed.

Sam McGuffie looks like the real deal. The offensive line was still sub-optimal against the Irish, and McGuffie had some impressive runs (and of course the screen pass). It was so kind of Perry Dorrestein to slam into McGuffie from behind on the touchdown screen.

Going forward, this game should probably give a little more hope to Michigan fans, though they are still disappointed for what could have been. I guess that’s what Michigan gets for RUNNING THE SPREAD OPTION IN HURRICANE KATRINA.

Posted under Analysis

Well… That Just Happened

So… that was a full-on Yakety Sax performance. Even with the threat of sounding like a huge homer, there was a lot of good in the game.

  • Threet looked like a solid QB. Between the throws down the field and how he took off on third and long for a first and goal, he made a lot of good decisions and the execution was there.
  • McGuffie is the real deal. I thought Shaw may have been the better TB after Miami, but McGuff was absolutely filthy all day.
  • The fade is a hard pass to defense
  • Stevie Brown made one or two mistakes. He also made a couple plays.
  • Special teams FTL!
  • Notre Dame spends it’s TV and Bowl money on the refs.

There will be more in depth analysis when I watch the game sober. Is it to mean to make a yakety sax montage for Michigan? I’m serious, it might be cathartic. Let me know.

UPDATE: Can I legitimately make fun of Weis for getting Paterno’d when Michigan got housed? I have ideas…

Posted under Analysis

Big Ten 2009 Recruiting Class Rankings 9-13-08

Action since last rankings:
9-8-08 Purdue gains commitment from Trevor Foy.
9-12-08 Michigan gains commitment from Anthony LaLota.

Michigan State and Notre Dame are virtually tied. So are Penn State and Wisconsin. Once a couple more commits drop to any of these schools, it will be a bit easier to differentiate them. I left Notre Dame ahead of State for now, because I think they are more likely to close out strong, unless there’s another 2007 on the way for the Irish.

New Rankings:

#1 Ohio State – 25 commits
LB ***** Dorian Bell
RB ***** Jaamal Berry
DT **** Johnny Simon
DE **** Melvin Fellows
CB **** CJ Barnett
WR **** James Jackson
MLB **** Storm Klein
MLB **** Jordan Whiting
RB **** Jordan Hall
OG **** Corey Linsley
OT **** Jack Mewhort
S **** Jamie Wood
WR **** Justin Green
RB **** Carlos Hyde
CB **** Corey Brown
S **** Bradley McDougald
WR **** Chris Fields
CB **** Dominic Clarke
WR *** Duron Carter
DE *** Jonathan Newsome
TE *** Reid Fragel
DT *** Adam Bellamy
FB *** Adam Homan
LB *** Zach Boren
OL *** Sam Longo
#2 Michigan – 17 commits
CB **** Justin Turner
QB **** Tate Forcier
QB **** Shavodrick Beaver
WR **** Bryce McNeal
RB **** Fitzgerald Toussaint
WR **** Jeremy Gallon
OL **** Michael Schofield
DT **** DeQuinta Jones
DE **** Anthony LaLota
S *** Isaiah Bell
WR *** DeWayne Peace
RB ***
Teric Jones
LB *** Jordan Barnes
S *** Mike Jones
K *** Anthony Fera
LB *** Brandin Hawthorne
RB *** Vincent Smith
#3 Notre Dame – 14 commits
RB ***** Cierre Wood
OL **** Chris Watt
RB **** Theo Riddick
DT **** Tyler Stockton
OL **** Alex Bullard
CB **** Marlon Pollard
LB **** Dan Fox
OL **** Zach Martin
S *** EJ Banks
TE *** Tyler Eifert
MLB *** Carlo Calabrese
K ** Nicholas Tausch
TE ** Jake Golic
P * Ben Turk
#4 Michigan State – 15 commits
RB **** Edwin Baker
RB **** Larry Caper
SLB **** Chris Norman
OL **** David Barrent
WR **** Donald Spencer
DT **** Blake Treadwell
QB **** Andrew Maxwell
WR *** Patrick White
WR *** Dana Dixon
LB *** Tyquan Hammock
OL *** Micajah Reynolds
OL *** Nate Klatt
DE *** Dan France
WR ** Bennie Fowler
TE ** Derek Hoebing
#5 Penn State – 16 commits
OT **** Eric Shrive
CB **** Darrell Givens
DE **** Sean Stanley
OT *** Mark Arcidiacono
S *** Stephen Obeng-Agyapong
S *** Malcolm Willis
S *** Derrick Thomas
C *** Ty Howle
CB *** Stephon Morris
WR *** Brandon Felder
OT *** Adam Gress
OL *** Nate Cadogan
RB ** Curtis Dukes
QB ** Curtis Drake
OG ** Frank Figueroa
WR ** Christian Kuntz
#6 Illinois – 14 commits
DT **** Lendell Buckner
OT **** Leon Hill
QB **** Nathan Scheelhaase
WR **** Kraig Appleton
RB **** Bud Golden
WR **** Terry Hawthorne
OL *** Andrew Carter
FB *** Greg Fuller
OL *** Hugh Thornton
WR ** Steve Hull
S ** Tommie Hopkins
CB ** Joelil Thrash
OL ** Jake Feldmeyer
LB ** Darryl Lee
#7 Wisconsin – 12 commits
DT **** Jared Kohout
DE **** Shelby Harris
OG *** Ryan Groy
QB *** Jon Budmayr
OT *** Zac Matthias
RB *** Montee Ball
TE *** Brian Wozniak
MLB *** Chris Borland
OL *** Travis Frederick
WR ** Jeff Duckworth
OL ** Casey Dehn
S ** Jason Peprah
#8 Minnesota – 9 commits
RB **** Hasan Lipscomb
RB **** Eric Stephens
QB *** Moses Alipate
C *** Ed Olsen
OT *** Josh Campion
WR *** Victor Keise
OL *** Brooks Michel
DE ** Nick Rengel
K ** Dan Orseske
#9 Indiana – 16 commits
LB *** Jeremy Gainer
QB *** Edward Wright-Baker
DT *** Adam Replogle
WR *** Jamonne Chester
WR *** Duwyce Wilson
OL *** Charles Chapman
QB *** Dustin Kiel
OL *** Colin Rodkey
CB ** Lawrence Barnett
DE ** Josh Keyt
S ** Nick Zachery
S ** Kenny Watkins
S ** Demetrius Carr
S ** Ted Bolser
OL ** Pat McShane
K ** Mitch Ewald
#10 Iowa – 6 commits
WR **** Keenan Davis
RB **** Brandon Wegher
WR *** Jordan Cotton
FB *** Brad Rogers
OL ** Drew Clark
OL ** Brett Van Sloten
#11 Northwestern – 7 commits
QB *** Evan Watkins
RB *** Mike Trumpy
DE *** Anthony Battle
WR ** Drew Moulton
OL ** Brian Smith
OL ** Taylor Paxton
OL * Tim Riley
QB
#12 Purdue – 6 commits
** Rob Henry
DE ** Trevor Foy
S ** Ishmael Aristide
WR ** Gary Bush
DE ** Shayon Green
DT * (JC) Kris Cooke

Posted under Recruiting

Comments Off on Big Ten 2009 Recruiting Class Rankings 9-13-08

Tags: ,

Anthony LaLota Goes Blue

Princeton, NJ prospect Anthony LaLota has pledged his intentions to become a Michigan Wolverine. LaLota, who attends The Hun School, stands 6-5, 260, and runs a very respectable 4.65-second 40-yard dash. Anthony is the 17th commitment in the class of 2009, and the #1 player in the state of New Jersey.

Recruiting Notes
Early in the process, Notre Dame was thought to be the prohibitive favorite for a verbal commitment from LaLota. With their three New Jersey commitments (including one from LaLota’s high school teammate Tyler Stockton), and nothing but effusive praise for the Irish from LaLota, it seemed his recruitment could have come to an end as early as June. Michigan’s offer came in June, and the Wolverines seemed to be an also-ran for LaLota’s services. Near the end of July, LaLota narrowed his impressive list of suitors to seven, and the Wolverines made the cut, though they were still considered an underdog. Late in August, Sam Webb reported on WTKA that LaLota’s decision would not be coming early, and that perhaps Michigan was stronger with Anthony than had previously been known, especially after the unofficial visit he had taken the previous weekend. LaLota also tentatively scheduled an official visit for the Wisconsin game. Then, this week, LaLota’s recruitment came to a head. Michigan and Penn State emerged as his rumored top 2, with other sources reporting that he would either pick a Big East/ACC school or Michigan. When he scheduled his announcement for Friday night at 8, Michigan fans were cautiously optimistic that he would don a block-M cap. LaLota did indeed pick Michigan, and is the 17th commitment in the class.

Player Notes
LaLota is something of an oddity, in that early on, both recruiting services ranked him at offensive tackle, and both gave him five stars. Despite this ranking, LaLota insisted that nearly every school recruiting him wated him as a defensive end. Eventually, Rivals wised up and switched his position, dropping him to four stars in the process. Scout maintains that he is an offensive tackle, and they still give him five stars (and a #3 position ranking) as an offensive lineman. Rodriguez and company recruited LaLota at end, and that will likely be his final college destination. As a strongside defensive end, LaLota is more of a run-stuffer than elite pass-rusher. However, he is not particularly polished, and will likely add some finesse moves to his repertoire in college. One exciting thing about LaLota is that his game is all based on physical talent at this time. He has only been playing football for a couple years, and is loaded with potential upside.

Request
If anyone can digitize the CSTV announcement by LaLota, e-mail me and we’ll get it up on VB.

Posted under Recruiting